Selecting and monitoring retirement plan service providers is an important fiduciary responsibility. Yet even sponsors who are generally satisfied with their current providers may wonder whether they're receiving competitive pricing, appropriate services and the technology their employees need.
One way to find out is through a request for proposal (RFP), a structured process that invites competing providers to submit detailed information about their services, capabilities and fees.
An RFP can uncover opportunities to improve a plan, but it also requires time and resources. Knowing when to initiate one—and when a less extensive review may be sufficient—can help sponsors make better decisions while demonstrating prudent fiduciary oversight.
Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), plan fiduciaries must prudently select and monitor service providers, including recordkeepers, investment advisors and third-party administrators. However, ERISA does not require sponsors to conduct an RFP every three, five or any other specified number of years. What matters is maintaining a prudent, documented process for evaluating providers and determining whether their services and fees remain reasonable.
For some plans, periodic benchmarking may provide sufficient information. For others, changes in circumstances or persistent service problems may justify a formal competitive search. The Department of Labor emphasizes that fiduciaries should regularly review provider performance, fees and participant complaints and determine whether existing arrangements remain appropriate.
One of the clearest reasons to consider an RFP is concern about plan expenses.
Recordkeeping and administrative fees can change as plans grow, service arrangements evolve and marketplace competition increases. A pricing structure negotiated several years ago may no longer reflect the value of the services being delivered.
Benchmarking can help identify whether fees remain reasonable compared with similarly sized plans receiving comparable services. If significant discrepancies emerge, sponsors may first seek revised pricing from their current provider.
If those discussions fail to produce satisfactory results, an RFP can establish what competing providers are willing to offer. It’s important to note that the lowest bid isn't necessarily the best choice. Fiduciaries should evaluate total costs alongside service quality, capabilities and participant experience.
Persistent service problems may be another indication that it's time to test the marketplace.
Warning signs include frequent relationship manager turnover, delayed responses, recurring administrative mistakes, unresolved participant complaints and difficulty obtaining accurate plan information.
Occasional problems are inevitable, but repeated issues can increase the administrative burden on human resources and benefits personnel while undermining participant confidence. Before initiating an RFP, sponsors should communicate concerns, establish measurable service expectations and give the provider an opportunity to improve. If problems persist, a competitive review may be warranted.
A provider that was an excellent fit several years ago may not be the best choice today.
Significant growth in plan assets or participant counts, mergers and acquisitions, changes in workforce demographics or the introduction of new plan features can create different administrative and service needs.
For example, a growing organization may require more sophisticated payroll integration, reporting capabilities, participant communication or support for multiple locations. An RFP can help determine whether the current provider has the resources and expertise to support the plan's evolving requirements.
Technology is increasingly important to both plan administration and participant engagement. Sponsors may want to evaluate whether their recordkeeper offers intuitive digital platforms, mobile access, personalized financial guidance, retirement readiness tools, cybersecurity protections and efficient administrative workflows.
Other emerging capabilities, including managed accounts, retirement income solutions and expanded financial wellness services, may also influence provider evaluations. If the current provider cannot deliver capabilities that are important to the plan's participants, an RFP can help identify alternatives.
The objective isn't necessarily to obtain the newest technology, but to determine whether available services meet the plan's needs.
Contract renewals, significant fee increases, service model changes or provider mergers can create natural opportunities for a formal review. These developments may alter pricing, staffing, technology platforms or the services included in an existing agreement.
Sponsors should review contractual provisions, including termination requirements, service commitments and potential transition expenses, before beginning a search. A major provider change doesn't automatically require an RFP, but it should prompt an evaluation of whether the existing relationship continues to serve the plan effectively.
Not every review needs to become a formal bidding process. Benchmarking compares a plan's fees and services with relevant marketplace data and similarly situated plans. It can help sponsors identify potential concerns without the time and expense of soliciting detailed proposals.
An RFP is more comprehensive. It typically involves defining plan requirements, inviting qualified providers to compete, comparing written proposals, conducting interviews and evaluating finalists against established criteria.
For plans that are generally satisfied with their providers, benchmarking may be sufficient. When significant concerns arise or the plan's needs have changed substantially, a full RFP may be more appropriate. Regardless of the approach, documenting the review and resulting decisions remains essential.
One important point is that conducting an RFP doesn't obligate a sponsor to replace its current provider. The incumbent may emerge as the strongest candidate, particularly after demonstrating competitive pricing or agreeing to service improvements. In that case, the process can validate the existing relationship while providing valuable documentation of fiduciary oversight.
Sponsors should also consider the costs and disruption associated with changing providers, including participant communications, asset transfers, payroll integration and potential blackout periods. A new provider should offer meaningful advantages that justify those transition considerations.
For sponsors already working with a retirement plan advisor, the advisor can help determine whether benchmarking or a formal RFP is appropriate. Advisors can assist with developing evaluation criteria, identifying qualified providers, analyzing proposals, comparing fees and services, and documenting the selection process. They can also help negotiate improvements with the existing provider and coordinate a transition if a change is warranted.
For sponsors without an advisor, engaging an experienced retirement plan advisor may be a valuable first step. An advisor can provide marketplace perspective, help assess the plan's current arrangements and guide a competitive search. Sponsors should evaluate the advisor's qualifications, compensation and potential conflicts of interest before engaging their services.
Informational Resources: PLANSPONSOR: “What This Year’s RFPs Will Look Like” (May 1, 2023); “PLANSPONSOR Roadmap: Outsourcing and Provider Selection” (February 23, 2026); “2026 Recordkeeping Survey” (July 9, 2026); U.S. Department of Labor: “Working With Service Providers” (accessed October 20, 2026).
Kmotion, Inc., 12336 SE Scherrer Street, Happy Valley, OR 97086; 877-306-5055; www.kmotion.com
©2026 Kmotion, Inc. This newsletter is a publication of Kmotion, Inc., whose role is solely that of publisher. The articles and opinions in this publication are for general information only and are not intended to provide tax or legal advice or recommendations for any particular situation or type of retirement plan. Nothing in this publication should be construed as legal or tax guidance, nor as the sole authority on any regulation, law, or ruling as it applies to a specific plan or situation. Plan sponsors should always consult the plan’s legal counsel or tax advisor for advice regarding plan-specific issues.
This material is intended to provide general financial education and is not written or intended as tax or legal advice and may not be relied upon for purposes of avoiding any Federal tax penalties. Individuals are encouraged to seek advice from their own tax or legal counsel. Individuals involved in the estate planning process should work with an estate planning team, including their own personal legal or tax counsel.